DIY - RPM and Temperature Data Logger
© Mark Qvale - July, 2019
| |
| DIY Test Tool |
Introduction
Folks on RCGroups and FB have asked about some of the test tools I use to get the recommendations, charts and numbers I use in my posts. This article then describes one of those tools which has been in continuous development for some time.
This DIY tool came from a need to be able to test components at steady state power, current and RPM levels to fully understand the loads being placed on the components. The first version of this served to regulate the RPM at a steady state regardless of voltage supply to test battery packs and ESC's. I then re-created the tool to regulate the current pulled from the ESC to further test battery packs in a controlled environment without the need for an expensive lab quality power supply.
The latest effort was to work out what the best props are to use for an FPV fixed wing project. To do this I needed to be able to put the tool in a plane and capture the RPM and motor temp. The first way to do this is to program the flight controller and micro controller to display (OSD) and log these values. Another way, and the one described here, was to make the tool stand-alone with its own data logging capability so I could move it from plane to plane regardless of flight controller set-up.
Tool Description
The tool captures RPM and two temperature values and logs them to a Micro SD card as a CSV file type which can be read and analyzed in MS Excel.
- RPM is captured using a Hobbywing RPM sensor which is the same as the Eagle Tree and Spektrum RPM sensors.
- RPM can be set using the TX while flying as either direct pass-through or regulated rpm.
- Temperature is captured using two glass bead NTC3950 thermistors commonly found on 3D printer set-ups.
- One temp sensor is epoxied onto the motor cross mount and the other is slipped under the ESC shrink cover on the MosFet side.
- One extra radio channel is needed to activate the pass-through/regulated functions.
Parts
The following are the parts used in the latest version of this tool-
- 1. Arduino 5v/16mhz Pro Mini Board
- 2. Omron 5v SPDT Signal Relay
- 3. Hobbywing RPM Sensor
- 4. NTC3950 Thermistors
- 5. Pin headers
- 6. Double Sided Prototyping PCB
- 7. 2x 100k Ohm, 1/4 watt resistors
- 8. 2x 10nF (103) capacitors
Part descriptions
Arduino Pro Mini - I wanted a small board with enough IO to handle all the tasks. The Pro Mini or the Arduino Nano both easily fit the bill as does the Teensy LC board. The Pro Mini was finally selected because it works and I can find them for around $5 each.
Omron Relay - After trying many different software attempts to create a smooth pass-through mode for the signal from the flight controller directly to the ESC, I finally decided to use the normally closed side of a relay to accomplish this task. There are two reasons for this-
- 1. If the board fails for some reason the relay will close to direct pass-through making it possible to continue flying the plane.
- 2. Having a direct, hard wired pass-through makes it completely smooth which is important in how the regulated section of the software works.
- 3. Inexpensive ($1.79)
HobbyWing RPM Sensor - I actually started with an early Eagle Tree unit that had an issue with how the power wires were from the factor - Black = Positive, Red = Negative. While looking for a replacement I found the HobbyWing version which according to my O-scope produces the same output. Bonus is they are less than a quarter of the price of the Eagle Tree units ($4.49)
NTC3950 Thermistors - I selected this type of temp sensor because I had them already and they are really inexpensive ($1.40 ea). Also they are very easy to attach to the motor and ESC because of their size.
All together then, the parts for a single build cost me ~$18 plus any shipping.
Schematic
The schematic for this build can be seen here-
|
Board Build
Here are some images of the first few versions and close-ups of the latest build-
|
Some of the proto set-ups
|
|
| First flight set-up |
|
| Current board (top) |
|
| Current board (bottom) |
Code
Copy the following into a new Arduino sketch and load to the board-
/*
v15r1 - Added SPDT signal relay (mechanical) to get hard wired
pass-through and normally closed safety if there is a board fail.
*/
/*Project Details
Brushless motor ESC, adjustable (in flight) RPM regulator with
two temperature probes and data capture.
©Mark Qvale, 2019
Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 License
Arduino Board and Pins used-
Board - Arduino Pro Mini, Atmega 328P, 5v, 16mHz
Pin 2 - RPM rpm sensor pin
Pin 8 - Passthrough/Regulated switch channel
Pin 9 - ESC out
Pin 3 - RX/FC throttle in
Pin 4 - Relay trigger out
Arduino bord to Micro SD Card Shield Pins-
Pin 10 - CS
pin 11 - MOSI
pin 12 - MISO
pin 13 - SCK(CLK)
Items needed for this build-
1x Hobbywing RPM sensor for brushless motors
2x 100k or 10k thermistors
1x Nano or Pro-Mini board
1x Micro SD card shield
1x SPDT Signal relay, 5v
2x R1 resistors (see below)
2x 10nF (103) capacitors (to stabilize temp readings)
Temp sensor & resistors-
Glass bead thermistor 100k NTC3950
R1 = 100K ohms
10k thermistor
R1 = 10K ohms
Pin A0 is Temp 1 input
Pin A1 is Temp 2 input
Acknowledgements-
Tom Igoe for his data log example code
Adrian Li for the RPM counter section found at https://www.locarbftw.com/using-an-arduino-to-read-rpm-from-the-hobbywing-rpm-sensor/
*/
#include <Servo.h> // Servo control library - Servo (built-in) by Michael Margolis
#include <Filter.h> // Filter library - MegunoLink by Number Eight Innovation
#include <PID_v1.h> // Control Loop library - PID by Brett Beauregard
#include <PWM.hpp> // PWM reader library by Kamran Ahmad
#include <SPI.h> // Serial Peripheral Interface library by Arduino
#include <SD.h> // SD Card library by Arduino/Sparkfun
#define INTERRUPT_PIN 0 // defines pin 2 (0) as RPM interrupt
Servo escout; // create servo/esc object
/* adjustable variables for signal smoothing and PID parameters */
int rpmRND = 25; // rounding value for rpm signal (default 25)
int EFW = 10; // exponential filter weight (default 10)
int EFWB = 20; // exponential filter weight (default 20)
int PST = 50; // PID sample time (default 50)
float kP = 0.07; // PID proportional factor
float kI = 0.03; // PID integral factor
float kD = 0; // PID derivative factor
int avgN = 20; // temperature average number (default 20)
int period = 200; // data print period in ms (default 200)
float numpoles = 14; // number of motors magnet poles
/* global variables */
const int chipSelect = 10; // data write pin number
unsigned long time_now = 0; // print timer variable
volatile int interruptCount; // RPM count variable
unsigned long time = 0; // initialize time variable
int csw = 0; // switch state key 0
int nsw = 1; // switch state key 1
int switchState;
int relay = 4; // relay pin
int sig; // lower limit PWM signal variable
int thout; // regulated ESC throttle output variable
float thpwm; // RX/FC throttle input variable
float thrP = 0; // throttle percent variable
int tempPin0 = A0; // temperature read/compute variables
int tempPin1 = A1; //
int Vo0; //
int Vo1; //
float avgT1; //
float avgT2; //
float R1 = 10000; //
float logR2, R2, logR3, R3, T1, T2; //
float c1 = 1.009249522e-03; //
float c2 = 2.378405444e-04; //
float c3 = 2.019202697e-07; //
PWM thrIn(3); // setup pin 3 for throttle input using the PWM ibrary
/* Exponential filter setup */
ExponentialFilter<long> ADCFilter(EFW, 0); // rpm smoothing filter
ExponentialFilter<long> ADCFilterB(EFWB, 0); // throttle signal smoothing filter
/* PID controller setup */
double rpmset, rpm, pwmsignal; // define variables connected to the PID controller
PID myPID(&rpm, &pwmsignal, &rpmset, kP, kI, kD, DIRECT); // PID tune set-up (original PID tune values - 2,5,1)
void setup()
{
Serial.begin(115200); // start the serial monitor
rpm = 0; // initialize rpm variable
rpmset = 0; // initialize PID variable, rpmset
thrIn.begin(true); // begin reading throttle input (3)
escout.attach(9); // attach ESC object (9)
pinMode(relay, OUTPUT); // relay on/off switch pin (4)
pinMode(8, INPUT); // set pinmode on RX switch pin (8)
pinMode(INTERRUPT_PIN, INPUT); // set pinmode on RPM pin (2)
attachInterrupt(INTERRUPT_PIN,interruptFired, CHANGE); // set-up interrupt count on RPM pin (2)
myPID.SetSampleTime(PST); // PID sampling rate in milliseconds (default = 50)
myPID.SetMode(AUTOMATIC); // set PID mode, AUTOMATIC or MANUAL
myPID.SetOutputLimits(900, 2000); // set low and high pwmsignal limits
Serial.print("Initializing SD card..."); // see if the card is present and can be initialized
if (!SD.begin(chipSelect)) { //
Serial.println("Card fail, or not present"); //
while(1); //
}
Serial.println("card initialized."); //
File dataFile = SD.open("Data_Log.csv", FILE_WRITE); // name and open the CSV file
if (dataFile) {
dataFile.println("Time(s),Temp 1(F),Temp 2(F),RPM,Thr %,Switch"); // write the column headings to the csv file
dataFile.close(); // close file
}
}
void loop(){
time = millis(); // time in ms
thpwm = thrIn.getValue(); // capture throttle signal
ADCFilterB.Filter(thpwm); // throttle signal filter
thpwm = ADCFilterB.Current(); //
// +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Throttle Percent ++++++++++++++++++++++++++
thrP = thpwm; // copy throttle signal value
thrP = constrain(thrP, 990, 2010); // constrain values for mapping
thrP = map(thrP, 990, 2010, 0, 100); // map throttle values to percent throttle
// +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Temp 1 & 2 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Vo0 = analogRead(tempPin0); // read temp pin 0
R2 = R1 * (1023.0 / (float)Vo0 - 1.0);
logR2 = log(R2);
T1 = (1.0 / (c1 + c2*logR2 + c3*logR2*logR2*logR2));
T1 = T1 - 273.15; // temp in Celsius
T1 = (T1 * 9.0)/ 5.0 + 32.0; // temp converted to Farenheit
for(int i = 0; i < avgN; ++i){
avgT1 += T1;
}
avgT1 /= avgN;
avgT1 = int(avgT1);
Vo1 = analogRead(tempPin1); // read temp pin 0
R3 = R1 * (1023.0 / (float)Vo1 - 1.0);
logR3 = log(R3);
T2 = (1.0 / (c1 + c2*logR3 + c3*logR3*logR3*logR3));
T2 = T2 - 273.15; // temp in Celsius
T2 = (T2 * 9.0)/ 5.0 + 32.0; // temp converted to Farenheit
for(int i = 0; i < avgN; ++i){
avgT2 += T2;
}
avgT2 /= avgN;
avgT2 = int(avgT2);
/* +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Switch Pass through +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ */
if (pulseIn(8, HIGH) > 1600){ // pass-through switch position
digitalWrite(relay, LOW); // holds relay closed (NC relay)
csw=0; // switch state key
switchState = csw;
}
/* +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Switch RPM Regulation +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ */
if(pulseIn(8, HIGH) >= 900 && pulseIn(8, HIGH) <= 1600) // regulate RPM switch position
{
digitalWrite(relay, HIGH); // opens throttle pass-through relay
if(nsw != csw){ // checks switch state
rpmset = rpm; // creates rpm signal set-point for the PID controller
sig = thpwm+1; // PWM transfer value
delay(2); // relay delay (one time)
csw = nsw; // switch state cancel
}
switchState = nsw;
myPID.Compute(); // compute the PID pwmsignal correction
thout = pwmsignal; // converts PID pwmsignal to an integer for ESC output
thout = constrain(thout, sig, 2000); // sets PWM range based on PWM transfer value as the lower limit
escout.writeMicroseconds(thout); // send regulated throttle value to the ESC
}
/* +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Switch Safety +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ */
if(pulseIn(8, HIGH) < 900){ // sets escout to 0 if no or low switch pulse detected (safety)
escout.writeMicroseconds(0);
digitalWrite(relay, LOW); // sets pass-through relay closed
}
/* ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ RPM Signal Capture +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ */
noInterrupts(); // RPM count code
interruptCount = 0; //
interrupts(); //
delay(10); //
noInterrupts(); //
int critical_rpm = interruptCount; //
interrupts(); //
rpm = ((critical_rpm)*(60))/(numpoles)*100;
ADCFilter.Filter(rpm); // exponential smoothing filter enable
rpm = ADCFilter.Current(); // smoothing filter output
rpm = int(round(rpm/rpmRND))*rpmRND; // rpm converted to an integer and rounded
if(rpm <= 1000){
rpm = 99;
}
/* ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Datafile Write ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ */
if(millis() >= time_now + period){ // start print timer
time_now = millis(); // reset print timer
File dataFile = SD.open("Data_Log.csv", FILE_WRITE); // open the data log file
if (dataFile) { // if available, write
dataFile.print(time/1000); // write to card - time in seconds
dataFile.print(", ");
dataFile.print(avgT1); // write to card - Temp 1
dataFile.print(", ");
dataFile.print(avgT2); // write to card - Temp 2
dataFile.print(", ");
dataFile.print(rpm); // write to card - RPM
dataFile.print(", ");
dataFile.print(thrP); // write to card - Throttle percent
dataFile.print(", ");
dataFile.println(switchState); // write to card - Switch state
dataFile.close(); // close data card file
}
else {
Serial.println("Card error!");
}
}
/* ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Serial Monitor Output +++++++++++++++++++++++++++ */
Serial.print("\n RPM: ");
Serial.print(rpm);
//Serial.print(" set-point: ");
//Serial.print(rpmset);
//Serial.print(" Thr signal: ");
//Serial.print(thpwm * 2.2);
Serial.print(" state: ");
Serial.print(switchState);
Serial.print(" Thr %: ");
Serial.println(thrP);
}
/* ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ RPM Counter Increment +++++++++++++++++++++++++++ */
void interruptFired(){
interruptCount++;
}
See Also
TBA
Comments? Questions?
